Who is responsible if damage is caused to a subcontractor's works by a person or persons unknown, the subcontractor, contractor or employer?
Damage by persons unknown falls where the subcontract puts it. A non-standard protection clause can load the risk onto the subcontractor; the standard forms split it by cause and by the stage the work has reached.
It depends on the subcontract and the stage the work has reached: a non-standard protection clause can place the risk on the subcontractor, as WS Harvey v HL Smith shows, while under the JCT 2011 Standard Building Subcontract the subcontractor bears the risk until goods are fully, finally and properly incorporated, subject to the specified perils and contractor-negligence exceptions
It depends on the subcontract and the stage the work has reached. Under a non-standard subcontract that requires the subcontractor to provide all necessary protection, WS Harvey (Decorators) v HL Smith Construction held that the obligation to protect the works against damage from whatever cause, and to make good damage, rests firmly on the subcontractor. Where the JCT 2011 Standard Building Subcontract applies, the subcontractor bears the risk until goods are fully, finally and properly incorporated into the works, except damage by specified perils such as fire, storm or tempest, which falls on the contractor or employer under clause 6.7.1.1, and damage by the negligence of the contractor or another subcontractor, which falls on the main contractor under clause 6.7.1.2. Once goods are fully, finally and properly incorporated, clause 6.7.2 passes the risk to the contractor. Under the CECA Blue Form the subcontractor is at risk until the main works are substantially completed, unless Part II of the Fifth Schedule provides otherwise.
| Non-standard clauses | WS Harvey: all necessary protection loads the risk on the subcontractor |
| Specified perils | Fire, storm, tempest fall on the contractor or employer (clause 6.7.1.1) |
| Contractor negligence | Damage by the contractor or another subcontractor (clause 6.7.1.2) |
| Incorporated goods | Risk passes to the contractor once incorporated (clause 6.7.2) |
| CECA Blue Form | Subcontractor at risk until the main works are substantially complete |
The rest of this solution is for members
Fifty of the two hundred contractual solutions are free to read. This is one of the remaining hundred and fifty, which Premium and Pro carry.
See what Premium includesAlready a member? Sign in