De Silva v Dindial’s Hardware: a buyer who walks away on the completion date without a notice to complete loses its deposit

Judicial Committee of the Privy Council
Legal Analysis, 14 November 2026

Teresa De Silva v Dindial's Hardware Limited

Neutral Citation: [2026] UKPC 39

CourtJudicial Committee of the Privy Council, on appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Republic of Trinidad and Tobago
JudgesLord Lloyd-Jones, Lord Briggs, Lord Hamblen, Lord Doherty and Lord Snowden
Judgment13 November 2026
Hearing19 October 2026
JurisdictionTrinidad and Tobago
AppellantDindial's Hardware Limited (purchaser)
RespondentTeresa De Silva (vendor)
Case referencePrivy Council Appeal No 0119 of 2025
OutcomeAppeal dismissed; the vendor was entitled to forfeit the deposit

Summary

Dindial agreed to buy land from Mrs de Silva, who was herself buying it from the executor of an estate that had not yet obtained probate. The latest date for completion was 28 February 2017 and time was not of the essence. When completion did not happen, Dindial demanded its deposit back on 4 March 2017 without serving a notice to complete. The issue was whether it could treat the contract as at an end on the ground that Mrs de Silva had no title to convey.

Dindial said the vendor's lack of title let it walk away without any notice. Mrs de Silva said she had an enforceable contractual right to the land and that Dindial's demand was itself a repudiation. The trial judge found for Dindial. The Court of Appeal and the Board found for Mrs de Silva, who kept the deposit.

Background and facts

Mrs de Silva contracted on 12 October 2016 to purchase a Maraval freehold from Mr Kazim, executor of the late Ebrahim Kazim, for US$1.5 million. Recital E of that contract recorded that probate was awaited, set 28 February 2017 as the latest completion date and made clear that time for completion was not of the essence. On 10 November 2016 she contracted to resell it to Dindial for TT$13 million, taking a 10% deposit. Dindial had a copy of the earlier contract by then.

Clause 7 of the onward contract returned the deposit if the vendor could not complete because of a defect in title. Clause 8 let the vendor keep the deposit if the purchaser was unwilling or unable to complete on the date fixed. By 28 February 2017 probate had not been granted, the tax receipt and WASA clearance certificate had not been supplied, and Dindial had decided it would prefer not to proceed. Letters of administration with the will annexed followed on 23 June 2017. Dindial sued for the deposit in December 2017.

The issue

The appeal depended on how two settled conveyancing rules interact. Where time is not of the essence, a party cannot terminate for a missed completion date until it has served a notice making time of the essence, fixed a further reasonable date and seen that date pass. The exception is that a purchaser who discovers the vendor has neither title nor any enforceable right to obtain it may treat the contract as discharged at once.

Dindial argued that the vendor had nothing to convey on the completion date, so the exception applied. Before the Board it also raised for the first time the vendor's ability to fund her own purchase in US dollars, the form of the grant eventually obtained, and relief from forfeiture of the deposit. Mrs de Silva relied on her contract with the executor.

The decision

Lord Briggs gave the judgment of the Board. He declined to deal with the three new points. Each came too late: the funding point had never been pleaded, and the other two turned on evidence or findings that belonged at trial.

it would be a plain injustice, and contrary to its settled practice, for the Board to engage with it nowLord Briggs, paragraph 21

On the main point, the Board held that the exception rests on the vendor's duty to disclose a latent absence of title before contracting. A vendor who discloses at the outset that conveyance depends on an event outside its control has given the warning the rule is about.

Thus if the vendor makes it clear at the time of contracting (as here) that his ability to convey depends upon the happening of an event outside his control, such as his vendor's obtaining probate, then the purchaser can hardly use that fact as a basis for then treating the contract as at an end.Lord Briggs, paragraph 29

Mrs de Silva also had an enforceable right against the executor to have the property conveyed to her or to anyone she directed. Only the timing depended on probate.

That was a "when" rather than "whether" question.Lord Briggs, paragraph 31

With the exception out of the way, Dindial could not end the contract before a notice to complete had expired. Its demand of 4 March 2017 was a repudiation, which Mrs de Silva accepted, and the deposit was forfeited. The appeal was dismissed.

Practical implications

The Board recorded that the law of Trinidad and Tobago is the same as that of England and Wales in every relevant respect, so the reasoning reads across to English conveyancing. A Privy Council decision does not bind the English courts, but it can be cited in them.

The danger is the party that moves first. A buyer that ends the contract on a missed date without a notice is not excused by the seller's own delay, and becomes the party in repudiatory breach. Developers who buy sites dependent on probate or an onward chain face the same risk. The judgment is about the sale of land, but the same discipline applies when advising on termination for delay under any contract that does not make time of the essence and gives no express right to terminate. The no title exception is narrow and does not apply where the vendor has an enforceable right to the property and the delay was disclosed before contract.

Practice points

  1. Before terminating for a missed completion date, check whether time is of the essence, reading the contract against everything disclosed when it was made.
  2. If it is not, serve a notice to complete giving a reasonable further date, and terminate only after that date has passed.
  3. Do not rely on the no title exception where the vendor holds an enforceable contractual right to the property and the reason for delay was disclosed.
  4. Plead every point, including relief from forfeiture, at first instance; an appellate court is unlikely to hear it for the first time.
  5. Where a seller's title depends on probate or a chain, negotiate an express longstop date and a termination right rather than relying on the general law.